Look for the nutritional adequacy statement
The American Kennel Club explains that this statement, usually in small print on the side or back of the bag, says whether the food is complete and balanced for a life stage. AAFCO recognises four stages: gestation and lactation, growth, maintenance and all life stages. A food for maintenance is not meant for a growing puppy, so match the statement to your dog.
Foods without this statement, such as many treats and toppers, are not designed to be the whole diet.
Who checks pet food?
AAFCO says it does not regulate, test, approve or certify pet food. It writes model language that states and other authorities may adopt. In the United States the FDA and state authorities enforce pet food laws. Labels in Europe follow FEDIAF guidelines, which use the terms complete and complementary feed.
The ingredient list
Ingredients are listed in descending order by weight, so the first is the largest by weight. The AKC notes that each ingredient must be named individually and that by-products such as liver are not automatically bad. The list tells you what is in the food, but not how good the ingredients are.
Guaranteed analysis
Labels must show minimum percentages of crude protein and crude fat and maximum percentages of crude fibre and moisture. The numbers are on an as-fed basis, so a wet food and a dry food cannot be compared directly without adjusting for water.
What the food name means
The AKC describes four AAFCO naming rules. A food named for one ingredient, such as Beef Dog Food, must be at least 95% of that ingredient. If the named ingredients make up at least 25% but less than 95%, the name needs a word such as dinner, entree or platter. A name using with, such as Dinner with Beef, needs only about 3% of that ingredient. A flavour name needs only an amount that testing can detect.
Feeding directions and dates
Feeding directions are guidelines, not rules. Breed, temperament, activity and other factors change how much a dog needs, so check with your vet. The AKC also advises checking the best-by date, because old food can lose nutritional value and grow harmful bacteria or mould.
For more on choosing food, see the WSAVA global nutrition guidelines.